| 12/7/23 | 19:45 | H | Friendly | Merstham | 5-1 | | Martin, Ghannam, Torpey, Swaby, Divine | | | |
| 15/7/23 | 15:00 | H | Friendly | Haywards Heath Town | 3-0 | | Ghannam, Martin, Torpey | | | |
| 19/7/23 | 19:45 | H | Friendly | Crawley Down Gatwick | 3-1 | | Jenkins 2, Martin | | | |
| 22/7/23 | 15:00 | A | Friendly | Loxwood | 3-0 | | Martin 2, Jenkins | | | |
| 26/7/23 | 19:45 | H | Friendly | BroadbridgeHeath FC | 2-2 | | Jenkins, Martin | | | |
| 29/7/23 | 13:30 | H | Friendly | Farnham Town | 1-2 | | Jenkins | | | |
| 5/8/23 | 15:00 | H | FA Cup EP | Burgess Hill Town | 1-1 | 84 | Martin | | | |
| 8/8/23 | 19:30 | A | FA Cup EP Replay | Burgess Hill Town | 1-2 | 264 | Jenkins | | | |
| 12/8/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Metropolitan Police | 4-0 | 105 | Jenkins, Divine, Simeone, Ghannam | | | |
| 26/8/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Uxbridge | 1-2 | 83 | Jenkins | | | |
| 28/8/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Marlow | 1-6 | 179 | Jenkins | | | |
| 2/9/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Guernsey | 2-1 | 72 | Ghannam, Sheppard | | | |
| 9/9/23 | 15:00 | A | FA Trophy | Merstham | 3-0 | 112 | Swaby, Simeone, Odunaike | | | |
| 16/9/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Corinthian Casuals | 5-0 | 183 | Simeone, Odunaike, Ghannam, Martin (p), Swaby | | | |
| 23/9/23 | 15:00 | H | FA Trophy 2nd Qual | Badshot Lea | 3-5 | 91 | Nzelo, Torpey, Oldham | | | |
| 30/9/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Ascot Utd | 1-1 | 136 | Torpey | | | |
| 4/10/23 | TBC | H | Isthmian South Central | Leatherhead | 0-1 | 137 | | | | |
| 7/10/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Southall | 1-2 | 81 | Ghannam | | | |
| 10/10/23 | 19:45 | A | Isthmian South Central | South Park (Reigate) | 1-2 | 90 | OG | | | |
| 14/10/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Westfield | 0-3 | 81 | | | | |
| TBC | 19:45 | A | Southern Combination Cup | Horley Town | 2-3 | 78 | Ghannam 2 | | | |
| 28/10/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Hartley Wintney | 1-5 | 73 | Jenkins | | | |
| 11/11/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Ashford Town (Middx) | 1-1 | 68 | Simeone | | | |
| 18/11/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Binfield | 4-1 | 77 | Lloyd, Ghannam, Feeney-Hill, Jenkins | | | |
| 21/11/23 | 19:45 | A | Surrey Senior Cup | Ashford Town (Middx) | 3-0 | 56 | Swaby, Ghannam, Jenkins | | | |
| 25/11/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Chipstead | 3-2 | 125 | Martin 3 | | | |
| 28/11/23 | 19:45 | A | Isthmian South Central | Northwood | 1-5 | 105 | Ghannam | | | |
| 2/12/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Hanworth Villa | 1-2 | 82 | Jenkins | | | |
| 9/12/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Thatcham Town | 1-3 | 81 | Oldham | | | |
| 16/12/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Chertsey Town | 0-0 | 648 | | | | |
| 23/12/23 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Badshot Lea | 1-1 | 74 | Jenkins | | | |
| 26/12/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Raynes Park Vale | 0-0 | 302 | | | | |
| 30/12/23 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Guernsey | 2-4 | 758 | Oldham, Jenkins | | | |
| 3/1/24 | 19:45 | H | Isthmian South Central | Marlow | 0-3 | 94 | | | | |
| 13/1/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Corinthian Casuals | 2-0 | 111 | Jenkins, Ghannam | | | |
| 20/1/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Southall | 0-1 | 142 | | | | |
| 27/1/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Ascot Town | 1-0 | 74 | Oldham (pen) | | | |
| 31/1/24 | 19:45 | H | Isthmian South Central | South Park (Reigate) | 3-0 | 102 | Jenkins, Oldham (pen), Stewart | | | |
| 3/2/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Westfield | 1-1 | 120 | Stewart | | | |
| 13/2/24 | 19:45 | A | Isthmian South Central | Leatherhead | 0-1 | 286 | | | | |
| 17/2/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Hartley Wintney | 1-2 | 237 | Jenkins | | | |
| 24/2/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Northwood | 2-2 | 75 | Stewart, OG | | | |
| 27/2/24 | 20:00 | A | Surrey Senior Cup | Chertsey Town | 2-2 (3-4 on pens) | 253 | Martin 2 | | | |
| 9/3/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Ashford Town (Middx) | 1-4 | 66 | Lloyd | | | |
| 16/3/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Hanworth Villa | 1-2 | 244 | Smith | | | |
| 23/3/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Chipstead | 2-0 | 136 | Smith, Sheppard | | | |
| 30/3/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Uxbridge | 0-4 | 159 | | | | |
| 1/4/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Raynes Park Vale | 1-2 | 138 | O.Williams | | | |
| 6/4/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Metropolitan Police | 2-0 | 73 | Oldham, Holden | | | |
| 09/4/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Binfield (@Ascot Utd) | 0-2 | 82 | | | | |
| 13/4/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Badshot Lea | 1-0 | 103 | Nzelo | | | |
| 20/4/24 | 15:00 | H | Isthmian South Central | Chertsey Town | 0-2 | 164 | | | | |
| 27/4/24 | 15:00 | A | Isthmian South Central | Thatcham Town | 0-1 | 157 | | | | |
